A few people have asked my opinion on the whole octuplet-birth-to-single-mother-who-already-has-6-kids story. Since I write about big families, I guess it seems natural that I would have an opinion on this suddenly very big family.
But the truth is, I haven’t been able to muster up much of an opinion on this at all. It’s just too bizarre, with too many unanswered questions. First of all, I don’t feel like it is really a story about big families at all. It’s more a story about medical technology and the ethics of using it. If she’d opted to have fourteen babies one at a time (and at the age of 33, who knows if it even would have been possible for her to have that many more), her neighbors would roll their eyes but nationally none of us would take notice. No, this is really a story about fertility science gone out of whack, and not having a very strong working knowledge about the ins and outs of fertility treatment, it’s not something I feel especially qualified to weigh in on.
I do think it’s important to separate out all the issues before we start in with the outrage–if for no other reason than to make sure we’re pointing our outrage in the right direction. For example, I do think that it’s *possible* to be a great mom to 14 kids even without a partner, even while not financially self-sufficient, even while living with your mother and father. That doesn’t mean I’d advise anybody to sign on for that life voluntarily, especially when it sounds like they’ve got a lot of challenges already. I think that without support, caring for eight babies at once would be extremely difficult and taxing even if your mental state is very sound (and honestly, does anyone believe this woman’s really is?) I don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting to have a lot of kids, but I do think that a person of sound mental state would look at the six kids she’s already raising under strapped and cramped conditions–I won’t even start in on how she wound up with those kids in the first place–and decide that would have to be enough. And don’t even get me started on what kind of malpracticing doctor would implant 8 embryos in the first place. (Nor the question: how does a poor single mom of six find money for fertility treatment?)
There’s been a lot of speculation that the mom is doing this to be the next Jon & Kate, to get a reality show, to get attention–and yet from what I’ve seen it appears she’s avoiding the spotlight. Maybe she’s desperate, likely she’s emotionally troubled, hopefully she’s got a lot of support because no matter what we think, there are now fourteen children who are going to be raised in difficult circumstances. But the only outrage I can really muster up at this point is aimed at the medical professionals who allowed this to happen. Maybe they were duped as well, but I feel like anyone who is in a position to implant 8 embryos in a woman is in a position of great responsibility, and somewhere along the way, somebody shirked theirs.
I really do wish this woman–and mostly her children–the best of luck. They’re going to need it, because even if I’m wrong and this mother is of completely sound mind, and even if she somehow manages to be self-sufficient, and even if she turns out to be a fantastic mom, the court of public opinion is not going to look kindly on this family. Either way, I hope she doesn’t end up with a TV show. It would be taking all the things that are great about big families and turning them into yet another television spectacle that makes the viewer feel embarrassed about the state of humanity…and don’t we already have enough of those? Frankly, the fact that I sometimes get roped into watching episodes of Intervention and Rock of Love makes me feel dirty and depressed enough.







